Questions + Answers.
How is it being moderated and how will the quality fare? Will it be the best of the best or will anyone be approved?
Currently LinkedIn does not have any really good tools for moderating groups but I have been told that these things are on there way. So for now it's all skate, all skate. It's also important to keep in mind that this isn't a portfolio review (maybe one day we'll expand but for now lets keep it simple), the purpose of WSD+D is to form a strong network of peers, business contacts, and maybe a mentor or two.
We need another "best of the best club" like we need another eccentric British web designer sporting lamb chops--we already got one of those and he fits that role quiet nicely. Quality of applicants are a reflection of the web: All over the place. The group roster includes all the names most of us in web standards business would recognize immediately and there are many, many people who just haven't made a name for themselves yet or they are perfectly happy lurking in the back row, for now.
I'm sure there are quite a few who have zero business affiliating themselves with such a group as this but I'm not too concerned about that right now. When we start requiring members to wear sport coats with the WSD+D crest then we'll find a way to weed out the posers and groupies (unless they're willing pay an absurd amount of money to hang out in the clubhouse).
Do you have any criteria in mind for who joins the group? I've snooped around groups across different industries, but none have any specific criteria they require. I was curious if I would find one that make people pass a quiz or something.
This isn't high school. We're not going to hold standardized testing, nor am I, or anyone else, going to 'grade' exams. If people join and they clearly don't belong then I guess we'll all have to live in a post 9/11 world wherein some members might not actually know a thing about XHTML or, God forbid, actively use Frontpage 98.
We can all learn from each other and better not only ourselves, but the industry as a whole. It is definitely something I would love to be a part of.
That's what I was thinking.
"I'm curious about what you see as the upside."
I'd like to see us all learn from each other on how to work smarter, faster, and cheaper (see above). We'll see how it goes.

